All papers examples
Get a Free E-Book!
Log in
HIRE A WRITER!
Paper Types
Disciplines
Get a Free E-Book! ($50 Value)

Omission and the Moral Responsibility for Death, Coursework Example

Pages: 1

Words: 382

Coursework

 “… the physician’s omission can only bring about death on the condition that the patient’s disease will kill him in the absence of treatment. We may hold the physician morally responsible for the death if we have morally judged such actions as wrongful omissions.” (Callahan, 359)

Callahan tries to elaborate the circumstances the physician’s actions or lack of it can amount to death, possibly making the omission count as “killing.”  In his argument, he reiterates that physicians cannot be accountable for killing patients under all circumstances. He believes that true death can only occur when the underlying lethal disease which the practitioner failed to respond to was capable of causing death to the patient.

Over time, physicians have been accused of “killing” patients in circumstances where they failed to respond on time or under absolute failure. People fail to understand the difference between causality and culpability in that the physicians under these circumstances play no physical role in death but the lethal disease itself.  The author also resurrects the discussion of the culpability of causing death whereby he argues that it is not an absolute demonstration that the patient’s death makes the physicians culpable. Callahan asserts that these culpabilities are morally or ethically constructed by defining wrong and right. Therefore, moral culpability over death arises under circumstances where the responsibility of medical response had a moral definition. Therefore, the argument that a physician “kills” a patient should be understood as a moral construct and not the legitimate view of the situation that amounts to the responsibility of the death (54). Callahan further adds that this concept fails to withstand argument since, when the doctor performs the omission at the patient’s request or when the physician’s actions could not stop death from occurring, it does not amount to “killing.”

Essentially, Callahan reiterates that man does not cause death when he omits an action. It is the illness that causes physical death. Thereby culpability only exists in that the death of an individual occurs when the doctor allows a lethal condition to proceed to its fatal end. Further, he confirms that a doctor can only cause death when he introduces a lethal injection that proceeds to its lethal conclusion, leading to both physical and moral responsibility.

References

Callahan, D. (1992). When self-determination runs amok. The Hastings Center Report22(2), 52-55. https://www.jstor.org/stable/3562566

Time is precious

Time is precious

don’t waste it!

Get instant essay
writing help!
Get instant essay writing help!
Plagiarism-free guarantee

Plagiarism-free
guarantee

Privacy guarantee

Privacy
guarantee

Secure checkout

Secure
checkout

Money back guarantee

Money back
guarantee

Related Coursework Samples & Examples

Residential Sanitation Automation, Coursework Example

Contracting for Trash Table 1 presents information and analysis suggesting that the automated system with new technology will save the city money over time. Over [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 404

Coursework

Relevant Law and Process, Coursework Example

Part I Personal contact information: Elsa and Doug Gardner Alternative contact information: Representative contact information: Respondent contact information: Cornerstone Family Services. Grounds of Alleged Discrimination [...]

Pages: 2

Words: 637

Coursework

Venture Capital, Coursework Example

Alpha Ventures’ proposal has two different capitalization tables. The tables depend on whether the fiscal year 2000 revenues threshold of $500,000 will be met. Question [...]

Pages: 5

Words: 1292

Coursework

Veil Piercing in the Supreme Court, Coursework Example

Introduction Prest v. Petrodel [2013] UKSC 34 has been one of the most contentious cases in English company law for almost ten years. This case [...]

Pages: 12

Words: 3238

Coursework

Consumer Law, Coursework Example

Introduction The existing economic theory and taxonomic framework, which identifies consumers as ‘average,’ ‘vulnerable,’ ‘informed,’ or ‘confident,’ is a valuable tool for regulating consumer behavior [...]

Pages: 14

Words: 3725

Coursework

Banking Law – Critically Discuss Statement, Coursework Example

Maintaining client confidentiality is a core value in several professions, like law and banking. The notion behind secrecy is that sensitive information must be safeguarded [...]

Pages: 13

Words: 3530

Coursework

Residential Sanitation Automation, Coursework Example

Contracting for Trash Table 1 presents information and analysis suggesting that the automated system with new technology will save the city money over time. Over [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 404

Coursework

Relevant Law and Process, Coursework Example

Part I Personal contact information: Elsa and Doug Gardner Alternative contact information: Representative contact information: Respondent contact information: Cornerstone Family Services. Grounds of Alleged Discrimination [...]

Pages: 2

Words: 637

Coursework

Venture Capital, Coursework Example

Alpha Ventures’ proposal has two different capitalization tables. The tables depend on whether the fiscal year 2000 revenues threshold of $500,000 will be met. Question [...]

Pages: 5

Words: 1292

Coursework

Veil Piercing in the Supreme Court, Coursework Example

Introduction Prest v. Petrodel [2013] UKSC 34 has been one of the most contentious cases in English company law for almost ten years. This case [...]

Pages: 12

Words: 3238

Coursework

Consumer Law, Coursework Example

Introduction The existing economic theory and taxonomic framework, which identifies consumers as ‘average,’ ‘vulnerable,’ ‘informed,’ or ‘confident,’ is a valuable tool for regulating consumer behavior [...]

Pages: 14

Words: 3725

Coursework

Banking Law – Critically Discuss Statement, Coursework Example

Maintaining client confidentiality is a core value in several professions, like law and banking. The notion behind secrecy is that sensitive information must be safeguarded [...]

Pages: 13

Words: 3530

Coursework