Quantitative Research on Men Who Batter, Essay Example

Provide an example of qualitative peer reviewed research article and an example quantitative peer reviewed research article in criminal justice. Discuss why each approach was used

A Review of Quantitative Research on Men Who Batter

The purpose of this quantitative research article is to examine the characteristics of men who batter. The research also analyzes intervention strategies that are implemented in helping men resolve these behaviors. The end result of the research is to develop distinguishing profiles and social conditions of those who batter and those who do not. For example, a common characteristic of those who batter is depression. This research strategy requires a qualitative method since it uses levels of subjectivity and it is used to describe variations in qualities or kinds.

The New North Carolinians: Doing Justice for All in the Criminal Justice System

The purpose of this qualitative research is to analyze the North Carolina Hispanic population growth projections, economic impact and the increase in crime (i.e. gangs) as it relates to the Hispanic population. The article utilizes previous data from reports such as the 1998 study on Hispanic Crime and Victimization in North Carolina and the United States Census Bureau. The end result of the research is to develop systematic and qualifiable methods to target crime and other criminal justice deficiencies in North Carolina Hispanic communities. This research required a quantitative method since it required a metrical system.

Describe some ways that ideological or political bias in human inquiry influences criminal justice and security management research

Although In the United States, the democratic process accepts a person’s innocent until proven guilty, the greatest impact to shaping the legal system is from the influences and ideologies of political bias. One of the greatest challenges facing the legal system is the claim of personal bias and subjectivity within the judicial process. Some of these biases may result from cultural or religious beliefs, standards of morality and personal interpretations based on other external influences. As a result of this claim, many individuals have been cleared of wrongdoings, whether guilty or not. A good example of this would be how Americans, politicians and lawmakers view Muslims in this country. Is it possible for a Muslim who has been accused of a terrorist threat or act to possibly receive a fair trial in the United States? Is it possible for an African American man to receive a fair trial when faces with an all white jury?

Discuss why deception in criminal justice research may be necessary in certain situations. Describe and justify the use of deception in two examples of research

In order to determine whether deception is necessary in a criminal justice process, one must first define the ethical lines of what is acceptable and what is not. If a policeman, detective or attorney lies in court, their decision may be justified when it comes to saving the lives of others or saving the life of one. To the contrary, however, the public may view the “justifiable” deception as no different from the deception of a hardened criminal. In Skolnick’s journal “Deception by Police”, he reviews government cases where deception occurred in order to not only obtain the truth but to also protect the citizens. Two specific examples discussed in the journal is the Robert Kennedy wiretapping incident and Robert Daley’s surveillance justification. (Skolnick, 1997). Skolnick believes that legal deception strategies cause the judicial system to appear more as a game than a solid process for keeping the streets and its citizens safe.

References

Tolman, R. M., Bennett, L. W. (1990). A Review of Quantitative Research on Men Who Batter. Retrieved May 5, 2010 from web: http://jiv.sagepub.com/cgi/pdf_extract/5/1/87

Hayes, R., Dowd, K. and Collins, E. (2006). The New North Carolinians: Doing Justice for all in the Criminal Justice System. Retrieved May 5, 2010 from web: http://www.ncgccd.org/pdfs/pubs/hispanic_study.pdf

Skolnick, J. (2007). Deception by Police. Retrieved May 3, 2010 from web: http://www.lib.jjay.cuny.edu/cje/html/sample1.html