Disciplines
- MLA
- APA
- Master's
- Undergraduate
- High School
- PhD
- Harvard
- Biology
- Art
- Drama
- Movies
- Theatre
- Painting
- Music
- Architecture
- Dance
- Design
- History
- American History
- Asian History
- Literature
- Antique Literature
- American Literature
- Asian Literature
- Classic English Literature
- World Literature
- Creative Writing
- English
- Linguistics
- Law
- Criminal Justice
- Legal Issues
- Ethics
- Philosophy
- Religion
- Theology
- Anthropology
- Archaeology
- Economics
- Tourism
- Political Science
- World Affairs
- Psychology
- Sociology
- African-American Studies
- East European Studies
- Latin-American Studies
- Native-American Studies
- West European Studies
- Family and Consumer Science
- Social Issues
- Women and Gender Studies
- Social Work
- Natural Sciences
- Anatomy
- Zoology
- Ecology
- Chemistry
- Pharmacology
- Earth science
- Geography
- Geology
- Astronomy
- Physics
- Agriculture
- Agricultural Studies
- Computer Science
- Internet
- IT Management
- Web Design
- Mathematics
- Business
- Accounting
- Finance
- Investments
- Logistics
- Trade
- Management
- Marketing
- Engineering and Technology
- Engineering
- Technology
- Aeronautics
- Aviation
- Medicine and Health
- Alternative Medicine
- Healthcare
- Nursing
- Nutrition
- Communications and Media
- Advertising
- Communication Strategies
- Journalism
- Public Relations
- Education
- Educational Theories
- Pedagogy
- Teacher's Career
- Statistics
- Chicago/Turabian
- Nature
- Company Analysis
- Sport
- Paintings
- E-commerce
- Holocaust
- Education Theories
- Fashion
- Shakespeare
- Canadian Studies
- Science
- Food Safety
- Relation of Global Warming and Extreme Weather Condition
Paper Types
- Movie Review
- Essay
- Admission Essay
- Annotated Bibliography
- Application Essay
- Article Critique
- Article Review
- Article Writing
- Assessment
- Book Review
- Business Plan
- Business Proposal
- Capstone Project
- Case Study
- Coursework
- Cover Letter
- Creative Essay
- Dissertation
- Dissertation - Abstract
- Dissertation - Conclusion
- Dissertation - Discussion
- Dissertation - Hypothesis
- Dissertation - Introduction
- Dissertation - Literature
- Dissertation - Methodology
- Dissertation - Results
- GCSE Coursework
- Grant Proposal
- Admission Essay
- Annotated Bibliography
- Application Essay
- Article
- Article Critique
- Article Review
- Article Writing
- Assessment
- Book Review
- Business Plan
- Business Proposal
- Capstone Project
- Case Study
- Coursework
- Cover Letter
- Creative Essay
- Dissertation
- Dissertation - Abstract
- Dissertation - Conclusion
- Dissertation - Discussion
- Dissertation - Hypothesis
- Dissertation - Introduction
- Dissertation - Literature
- Dissertation - Methodology
- Dissertation - Results
- Essay
- GCSE Coursework
- Grant Proposal
- Interview
- Lab Report
- Literature Review
- Marketing Plan
- Math Problem
- Movie Analysis
- Movie Review
- Multiple Choice Quiz
- Online Quiz
- Outline
- Personal Statement
- Poem
- Power Point Presentation
- Power Point Presentation With Speaker Notes
- Questionnaire
- Quiz
- Reaction Paper
- Research Paper
- Research Proposal
- Resume
- Speech
- Statistics problem
- SWOT analysis
- Term Paper
- Thesis Paper
- Accounting
- Advertising
- Aeronautics
- African-American Studies
- Agricultural Studies
- Agriculture
- Alternative Medicine
- American History
- American Literature
- Anatomy
- Anthropology
- Antique Literature
- APA
- Archaeology
- Architecture
- Art
- Asian History
- Asian Literature
- Astronomy
- Aviation
- Biology
- Business
- Canadian Studies
- Chemistry
- Chicago/Turabian
- Classic English Literature
- Communication Strategies
- Communications and Media
- Company Analysis
- Computer Science
- Creative Writing
- Criminal Justice
- Dance
- Design
- Drama
- E-commerce
- Earth science
- East European Studies
- Ecology
- Economics
- Education
- Education Theories
- Educational Theories
- Engineering
- Engineering and Technology
- English
- Ethics
- Family and Consumer Science
- Fashion
- Finance
- Food Safety
- Geography
- Geology
- Harvard
- Healthcare
- High School
- History
- Holocaust
- Internet
- Investments
- IT Management
- Journalism
- Latin-American Studies
- Law
- Legal Issues
- Linguistics
- Literature
- Logistics
- Management
- Marketing
- Master's
- Mathematics
- Medicine and Health
- MLA
- Movies
- Music
- Native-American Studies
- Natural Sciences
- Nature
- Nursing
- Nutrition
- Painting
- Paintings
- Pedagogy
- Pharmacology
- PhD
- Philosophy
- Physics
- Political Science
- Psychology
- Public Relations
- Relation of Global Warming and Extreme Weather Condition
- Religion
- Science
- Shakespeare
- Social Issues
- Social Work
- Sociology
- Sport
- Statistics
- Teacher's Career
- Technology
- Theatre
- Theology
- Tourism
- Trade
- Undergraduate
- Web Design
- West European Studies
- Women and Gender Studies
- World Affairs
- World Literature
- Zoology
Activist Judges: Kelo V. the City of New London, Essay Example
Hire a Writer for Custom Essay
Use 10% Off Discount: "custom10" in 1 Click 👇
You are free to use it as an inspiration or a source for your own work.
The ruling in Kelo v City of New London unfairly and unjustly allows the seizure of private property for “public good.” In this case, several liberties were taken in determining whether private land could be seized for the benefit of a private entity. In analyzing the dissenting views of the Justices that demonstrated judicial restraint, it is evident that the ruling used judicial activism to determine the definition of “public use.”
Judicial activists believe that the U.S. Constitution is a living document and that there is room for interpretation. However, it is believed that all judicial activists do is try to” to usurp the duties and responsibilities of legislatures; that they seek to create a government-knows-best “nanny state;” that they are soft on crime and shift responsibility from the individual to society; and that they creatively and conveniently interpret the Constitution to fit politically-correct agendas.”[1] In this case, the Supreme Court “abused precedent, reinforcing grave errors by extending the misinterpretation of ‘public use’ as being the equivalent of ‘public purpose.’”[2] Not only was the ruling a failure, but also it turns out that the economic development that was going to revitalize the economy it the blighted community was never built and therefore the land was seized without purpose. Furthermore, the activists in this case reinterpreted the Fifth Amendment too liberally and redefined the meaning of “public good,” which the dissenting judges were under the impression that “public good” meant the public could use and benefit from the property that was taken; Justice Thomas contends, “States employed the eminent domain power to provide quintessentially public goods, such as public roads, toll roads, ferries, canals, railroads, and public parks,”[3] which is clearly not why property was seized in this case.
Judicial activism relates to Kelo v City of New London because it not only established that “public use” was equivalent to “public purpose,” but also established precedent. Additionally, the ruling of the Supreme Court prompted at least 37 states to pass legislation to protect private landowners from being subjected to eminent domain under similar circumstances.[4]
Bibliography
“Eminent Domain: Drawing the Line on Property Rights.” W.P. Carey School of Business at Arizona State University. November 10, 2009. http://knowledge.wpcarey.asu.edu/article.cfm?articleid=1824. (accessed April 3, 2012).
Kelo v. City of New London, 545 U.S. 469 (2005) (dissenting opinion)
“Kelo v. City of New London, Conn.” Order in the Court: Rule of Law Initiation.
http://orderinthecourt.org/Cases/Kelo-v-City-of-New-London-Conn.
Lesson 5: The Supreme Court.
[1] Lesson 5: The Supreme Court
[2] “Kelo v. City of New London, Conn.,” Order in the Court: Rule of Law Initiation, http://orderinthecourt.org/Cases/Kelo-v-City-of-New-London-Conn
[3] Kelo v. City of New London, 545 U.S. 469 (2005) (dissenting opinion)
[4] “Eminent Domain: Drawing the Line on Property Rights,” W.P. Carey School of Business at Arizona State University, November 10, 2009, http://knowledge.wpcarey.asu.edu/article.cfm?articleid=1824.
Stuck with your Essay?
Get in touch with one of our experts for instant help!
Time is precious
don’t waste it!
writing help!
Plagiarism-free
guarantee
Privacy
guarantee
Secure
checkout
Money back
guarantee