Home / Article Critique / How to Measure Student Success, Article Critique Example

How to Measure Student Success, Article Critique Example

Pages: 5

Words: 1466

In this video, Rashid Carter from Olive-Harvey College was the host. The subject matter of the video was public schools, testing and the concept of no child left behind.

Many issues were addressed, specifically how do public schools effectively assess the value of the education they are providing for students. Charter schools were identified as a solution for all of the failing schools that being closed down. The panel talked about charter schools and their effect on achievement. A panelist noted that charter schools are , “Not the answer but an answer.” The problem he noted was that No Child Left Behind forced teachers to teach towards tests. He noted this was a negative effect of the policy. He also identified a positive aspect of No Child Left Behind as the emphasis on setting standards for excellence, even if these standards were misguided. One key argument mentioned in favor of charter schools was that they expand school days and allow students to have more time learning tasks.

The ultimate influence this could have on business would be if my business were involved in the education industry, or if this ultimately resulted in improvements in the groups of potential employees. There is undeniably a lot of money to be made investing in charter school development, or even technology to improve the learning process within the educational system. Economically, improving the educational system leads to an increase in skilled workers and less need for outsourcing.

In sum, I agree with many of the arguments posed by this panel. Many of the failed policies within the education system were put on blast, but the panel did appeare to be stumped to pose new solutions. Charter schools were identified as one solution, but it was also acknowledged that

The Professors: Wall Street and America’s Economic Health

Host Winter Palacio Professors Linda Murphy and Antonio Vascez from Wilbur Wright College and economist Michael Muitt talk about the economy and its current stat, but more importantly where it’s headed.

They noted that a person localizes the national economy, and information they see about the economy on the news, by assessing the value of products they buy when going at the store, paying attention to the price change in gas, and recognizing when small stores closed on their neighborhood. These were all recognized as factors to truly assess the credibility of economic reports

Vascez talks about how economics is a religion. By this he means that people have fundamental beliefs about economics that they hold on to at times even when they are not best for the country. He notes that politics has a significant effect on how the economy shifts, because politicians have political incentives to do things that are not in the best interest of citizens. The closing theme of the video was that every individual needs to get their financial house in order. Murphy mentions her experience as a motorcycle saleswoman. She points out that before the economic crisis, when individuals would come in to purchase a motorcycle, they almost always did it through financing and they were rarely ever turned down. She noted that most of these people had credit scores between 350 and 550, which she argued was too low to be approved. She said their biggest worry was always whether or not they could afford the monthly payments and the same exact thing happened with the housing industry. The panel counters this point with the paradox of being frugal. They say now that the U.S. is recovering for the recession, many people are saving their money and not spending it, but that this is not the solution for improving the economy because every dollar spent is a dollar earned by someone else.

As far as business is concerned, this is the most essential factor in deciding whether or not a business can thrive. The health of the economy is ultimately the health of the nation. I think future success for any business, mine or that of anyone else, will basically come down to whether or not people are employed to spend money.

I agree with much of the information posed by this panel. The main argument I agreed with was Murphy’s argument that the economy is not all bad, and that one does not need to listen to the news, but can walk down the street of their neighborhood and decide on their own he state of the economy.

The Professors on Foreign Policy

In this video, Rashid Carter from Olive-Harvey College was the host. The panel includes, Professors Antonio Vascez from Wilbur Wright College, Shawn Dimpfl from University of Illinois, and Agber Dimah Chicago State University. The topic of the video is regime change in the global economic and political sphere.

Dimah argues that states act in their own interests. Vascez notes that the U.S. is in Libya He talks about the “power elite” and how they are the ones who ultimately decide foreign policy, specifically where the U.S. should go and not go Dimah argues that in order for the U.S. to intervene in foreign conflicts it has to be in the economic interest in the U.S. He is arguing that the U.S. does intervene in international conflicts for humanitarian purposes. Vascez argues that with the death of Osama Bin Laden, the U.S. is no longer in the “post 9/11 era” but now in a pre-era of something else. Dimah argues that Obama has embraced internationalism more than George W. Bush.

On a business level, this information can be beneficial if one believes that the United States is continuing business as usual in terms of its foreign policy, but Dimah argues there is a significant change in how Obama is handling Foreign policy.

I agree with Dimah and his point of view that the U.S. rarely gets involved in situations where they do not have economic or political interests. I also agree that foreign policy is dictated by the power elite.

The Professors on Presidential Election 2012

In this video the host is Ted Williams of Kennedy-King College. The panel included Agber Dimah of Chicago State University, Nick Panametros from Kennedy-King College, Connie Mixon from Elmherst College, and Rafael Riverdinera from the Republican National Hispanic Assembly.

In this video the Professors opened with interviewed individuals on the street and asked them who they would vote for in the upcoming election. Many people said that they would vote for Barack Obama, but there were a large number of people who provided a depth of reason to why they would not vote for him. One of the main reasons noted by those who mentioned they would not vote for Obama included the economy. Nick Panametros opens by arguing that Mitt Romney is a centrist. His view is supported by Riverdinera who argues that most people who disagree with this are left of center. The panel overall believes that the election will be close. This particular panel is very impassioned about this topic. Their politics become very clear. The majority of the panel is Democratic, and while Riverdinera is the only open Republican, Panametros appears to be a Republican too intimidated to speak his mind.

This information can be significantly influential on business, in that the President will ultimately decide the policies that will drive the economy in the years to come. Mitt Romney does of executive experience, so nominating a Republican candidate who tend to be stern on economic policy could be the perfect adrenalin shot that the U.S. needs, and it could results in less regulations to empower small businesses. Likewise, the panel does touch on the topic that Obama has et with a large amount of resistance from congress.

In sum, I agree that the election will definitely be close in 2012. I also think that there will be a large number of voters who voted for Barack Obama in 2008 who will either not vote out of disinterest or vote for any candidate except Barack Obama. I also believe that Mitt Romney won’t be able to win, due to the successes that Barack Obama has had internationally, which is one of the main criticisms that was posed against him in 2008.