Hire writer
Paper Types
Disciplines

On Possible Limitations of Hume’s Concept of the Miracle, Research Proposal Example

Pages: 1

Words: 363

Research Proposal

Proposal:

In his text »Of Miracles«, Hume proposes a critique of the concept of miracle based upon the notion that a miracle is a form of »violation« of the laws of nature. Accordingly, a miracle can only be said to appear against the backdrop of consistent laws of nature: if this were not the case, the miracle could never be experienced as a miracle. But if the miracle is dependent upon the law of nature, how can this be reconciled with the notion that the miracle is essentially dependent upon God by definition, i.e, the miracle is a sign of the existence of God? By thinking about miracles in terms of the divine, perhaps Hume’s concept of miracle becomes too limited, and therefore his critique of miracle also fails to address the divine aspect of miracle. In other words, he only approaches the miracle from the perspective of the human obserever, and thereby misses the crucial divine aspect of the miracle.

Annotated Bibliography:

David Hume, »Of Miracles.«

In the text, Hume introduces his famous critique of the concept of miracle. Hume can be said to take a certain empirical approach the phenomenon of the miracle, analyzing the miracle in terms of categories such as evidence and the witnessing of the miracle itself. Hume, however, fails to see how the witnessing of the miracle corresponds to the evidence of the miracle itself. This disjunction explodes apart what may be termed the »consistency of the miracle«, thus making this concept untennable according to his approach.

Ward, Keith. »Believing in Miracles.« Zygon, Vol. 37, No. 3, September 2002.

Ward takes a critical approach to Hume’s argument presented in »Of Miracles«, taking what could be called a »positive« view of miracles as opposed to a »negative« view of miracles. In other words, to the extent that Hume views the miracle as a »violation« of the law of nature, it is defined negatively in terms of consistent laws of nature. Ward, in contrast, aims for a positive account, showing the indication of a world that lies beyond the natural world. Ward’s text is invaluable in thinking about how the concept of miracle can be extended beyond the manner in which Hume defines it.

 

 

 

Time is precious

Time is precious

don’t waste it!

Get instant essay
writing help!
Get instant essay writing help!
Plagiarism-free guarantee

Plagiarism-free
guarantee

Privacy guarantee

Privacy
guarantee

Secure checkout

Secure
checkout

Money back guarantee

Money back
guarantee

Related Research Proposal Samples & Examples

Women’s Changing Roles in Saudi Arabia, Research Proposal Example

Introduction  In the 2008 documentary film Inside the Saudi Kingdom, director Lionel Mill was granted unprecedented access inside the personal and professional life of Prince [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 1319

Research Proposal

The Effectiveness of Personal Protection Equipment, Research Proposal Example

The Effectiveness of Personal Protection Equipment (PPE) in Various Industries In his article for Professional Safety magazine, Jason Dean points out that in order to [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 576

Research Proposal

Diabetes as an Urban Health Issue, Research Proposal Example

Diabetes Mellitus Diabetes mellitus is a metabolic disorder being described as a nutritional disease. It is considered an urban health issue because more people residing [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 270

Research Proposal

Observations Page, Research Proposal Example

Ten people will constitute the sample to be used for observation purposes.  The sample to be observed will be selected from the same population chosen [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 275

Research Proposal

Can a Man and Woman Be “Just” Friends With No Sexual Desire, Research Proposal Example

Introduction Men and women interact in many ways in different circumstances. Platonic relationships are a reality but the big question that many cross-sexual platonic friends [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 994

Research Proposal

More Active Learning for ESL Learners, Research Proposal Example

Better Resources and More Active Learning for Our ESL Learners; What We Can Do in the Classroom Nothing is scarier for an elementary aged child [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 1632

Research Proposal

Women’s Changing Roles in Saudi Arabia, Research Proposal Example

Introduction  In the 2008 documentary film Inside the Saudi Kingdom, director Lionel Mill was granted unprecedented access inside the personal and professional life of Prince [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 1319

Research Proposal

The Effectiveness of Personal Protection Equipment, Research Proposal Example

The Effectiveness of Personal Protection Equipment (PPE) in Various Industries In his article for Professional Safety magazine, Jason Dean points out that in order to [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 576

Research Proposal

Diabetes as an Urban Health Issue, Research Proposal Example

Diabetes Mellitus Diabetes mellitus is a metabolic disorder being described as a nutritional disease. It is considered an urban health issue because more people residing [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 270

Research Proposal

Observations Page, Research Proposal Example

Ten people will constitute the sample to be used for observation purposes.  The sample to be observed will be selected from the same population chosen [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 275

Research Proposal

Can a Man and Woman Be “Just” Friends With No Sexual Desire, Research Proposal Example

Introduction Men and women interact in many ways in different circumstances. Platonic relationships are a reality but the big question that many cross-sexual platonic friends [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 994

Research Proposal

More Active Learning for ESL Learners, Research Proposal Example

Better Resources and More Active Learning for Our ESL Learners; What We Can Do in the Classroom Nothing is scarier for an elementary aged child [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 1632

Research Proposal