Hire writer
Paper Types
Disciplines

Organizational Usability of Digital Libraries: Case Study of Legal Research in Civil and Criminal Courts by Margaret Elliot and Rod King, Article Review Example

Pages: 1

Words: 608

Article Review

Introduction

Article summary

Organizational Usability of Digital Libraries: Case Study of Legal Research in Civil and Criminal Courts is an investigation into how organizational usability of LRDL systems can be characterized and how they vary across organizations. Also, an evaluation into how institutional and cultural influences affect adoption and usage patterns of LRDLs was done as well as how the organization’s environment affects this process. Finally, an exploration into conditions impeding implementation of LRDLs was undertaken (Elliot & King, 1997).

The researchers applied institutional theories in explaining their findings after admitting that knowledge pertaining to the requirements for configuring an appropriate online CD-ROM LRDL’s could be very useful. Importantly, LRDLs are modern document storage devices. Hence, a research into its applicability across organizations was vital in an advanced information technology age (Elliot & King, 1997).

 

Discussion

 Design and Methodology

This research design encompassed an ethnographic study of LRDLs within California, Los Angeles civil courts jurisdiction. A qualitative approach was established in explaining findings. As such, very little statistical interpretations were applied when compared to a quantitative study design (Elliot & King, 1997).

The sampling was done using a purposive non- probability technique, which limited results to the sample selected as well as the geographic location used for this case study. They consisted of a Municipal court, a superior court and a law firm within the California location. This sample was validated as being most appropriate because of the high LRDL technology they contained, which was necessary for best evaluation of the system. Researchers collected data by conducting field work in the selected courts’ libraries for 11 months. During the last 5 months observation embodying 10-20 hours weekly was undertaken. Interviews were also used as a data collection strategy (Elliot & King, 1997).

Court documents were perused. Structured interviews were conducted with a sample of attorneys, judges and court reporters. Combing these elements the first researcher volunteered as an attorney participant observer of the process at one of the courts. This extensive use of different data collection strategies could be beneficial to this study because the variety of tools means that a diversity of data could be collected from the study. Therefore, internal validity could be established.

However, when examining the interviewing technique applied, internal validity of the instrument could be questioned. There was no pretesting in establishing reliability. How accurate were items on the interviewing schedule in relation to the answering research questions? Further, the researchers explained that they interviewed 46 professions; 22 PD’s; 3 PD administrators; 3 DA’s; 7 Judges; 4 court reporters; I criminal defense attorney; I paralegal; 3 civil attorneys and two information system specialists (Elliot & King, 1997).

Categories applied from Markus and Robey’s organizational validity concept were used to analyze data collected both from interviews and observation.  Theoretical applications also rendered validity during these qualitative interpretations. They include dimensions of organizational usability and institutional theory (Elliot & King, 1997).

 Conclusion

Results and Conclusions

These researchers interpreted their results through applying the concepts and theoretical perspectives mentioned in the data analysis portion of this article review. They discovered a great environmental influence on organizational usability of LRDLs. Organizational usability of LRDLs was characterized by utilizing a three dimensions framework namely, individual, organization and environment (Elliot & King, 1997).

Further, the  researchers identified that access points within an organization influence adaptions to LRDLs. There is a strong relationship between computer literacy at the individual level at home and work adaptability. Ultimately, while training is necessary in usability of LRDL many of programs are not effective (Elliot & King, 1997).

References

Elliot, M., & King, R. (1997). Organizational Usability of Digital Libraries: Case Study Of Legal Research in Civil and Criminal Courts. Journal of American Society for Information Science. 48(11); 1023–1035

 

 

 

Time is precious

Time is precious

don’t waste it!

Get instant essay
writing help!
Get instant essay writing help!
Plagiarism-free guarantee

Plagiarism-free
guarantee

Privacy guarantee

Privacy
guarantee

Secure checkout

Secure
checkout

Money back guarantee

Money back
guarantee

Related Article Review Samples & Examples

How to Cure Common Cold Symptoms, Article Review Example

Introduction The term common cold is used to refer to a viral infection of the upper respiratory tract, the single most frequent condition in humans. [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 511

Article Review

“Our Son Obama” by Philister Adhiambo Madiega, Article Review Example

Introduction The author discusses the dream, hopes and disappointments of people of western Kenya using various artistic aspects such as visual aspects. Other than illustrating [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 893

Article Review

Patient-Centered Medical Home, Article Review Example

Introduction Primary health care is the provision of health care services by the clinicians who understands a wide range of health problems of the patients. [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 272

Article Review

Google’s Email Is Halted In Iran, Article Review Example

Christopher Rhoads, Chip Cummins, Jessica E. Vascellaro. Wall Street Journal. (Eastern edition). New York, N.Y.: Feb 11, 2010. pg. A.11 Abstract (Summary) The regime, through its telecom arm, the Telecommunication [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 1480

Article Review

Predicting Teachers, Article Review Example

Predicting Teachers’ and Schools’ Implementation of Olweus Bullying Prevention Program: A Multilevel Study by Jan Helge Kallestad and Dan Olweus What constitutes the process of [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 724

Article Review

Testing a Web Information Portal for People With Learning Disabilities, Article Review Example

Abstract This paper contributes to an incremental base of research exploring usability issues related to information and communication experiences and needs of individuals with learning [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 6574

Article Review

How to Cure Common Cold Symptoms, Article Review Example

Introduction The term common cold is used to refer to a viral infection of the upper respiratory tract, the single most frequent condition in humans. [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 511

Article Review

“Our Son Obama” by Philister Adhiambo Madiega, Article Review Example

Introduction The author discusses the dream, hopes and disappointments of people of western Kenya using various artistic aspects such as visual aspects. Other than illustrating [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 893

Article Review

Patient-Centered Medical Home, Article Review Example

Introduction Primary health care is the provision of health care services by the clinicians who understands a wide range of health problems of the patients. [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 272

Article Review

Google’s Email Is Halted In Iran, Article Review Example

Christopher Rhoads, Chip Cummins, Jessica E. Vascellaro. Wall Street Journal. (Eastern edition). New York, N.Y.: Feb 11, 2010. pg. A.11 Abstract (Summary) The regime, through its telecom arm, the Telecommunication [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 1480

Article Review

Predicting Teachers, Article Review Example

Predicting Teachers’ and Schools’ Implementation of Olweus Bullying Prevention Program: A Multilevel Study by Jan Helge Kallestad and Dan Olweus What constitutes the process of [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 724

Article Review

Testing a Web Information Portal for People With Learning Disabilities, Article Review Example

Abstract This paper contributes to an incremental base of research exploring usability issues related to information and communication experiences and needs of individuals with learning [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 6574

Article Review