Sossong and Poirer, Article Critique Example

Introduction

An article by Sossong and Poirer (2013) addresses the importance of caring and the different perceptions that exist regarding this concept in rural settings in the United States. This article compared the perceptions of nurses and patients in order to determine if the concepts of current practice settings are aligned with patient-centered care objectives in rural healthcare organizations (Sossong and Poirer, 2013).

Analysis

The article offers a comprehensive literature review of resources that address caring in greater detail, using information from the Institute of Medicine and principles regarding historical theories and how they align with caring principles (Sossong and Poirer, 2013). The introduction of research regarding caring is also essential to this section and provides further evidence of the differences regarding caring between nurses and patients, as their perceptions are unique and diverse (Sossong and Poirer, 2013).

The study summarizes the use of a research instrument known as the CBI-E to address caring, using Jean Watson’s theory of the concept (Sossong and Poirer, 2013). The methods section is clear and describes the patient population, the inclusion and exclusion criteria, and level of power. The study also describes the procedure, the data analysis that was conducted, and the results in great detail. These sections support the original study objectives and provide further evidence of the distinction of caring between nurses and patients (Sossong and Poirer, 2013). The study concludes with a practical discussion of implications for policy that support the arguments that have been made (Sossong and Poirer, 2013).

Conclusion

Overall, the study is successful in providing information regarding the different perceptions of caring as they are observed in nursing practice settings, as nurses and patients possess unique perceptions of this phenomenon and how it impacts practice settings as a whole.

References

Sossong, A., & Poirer, P. (2013). Patient and nurse perceptions of caring in rural United States. International Journal for Human Caring, 17(1), 79-84.