Back to School Offer

Get 20% of Your First Order amount back in Reward Credits!

Get 20% of Your First Orderback in Rewards

All papers examples
Get a Free E-Book! ($50 Value)
HIRE A WRITER!
Paper Types
Disciplines
Get a Free E-Book! ($50 Value)

Warning Labels for Hot Dogs, Article Critique Example

Pages: 2

Words: 621

Article Critique

Lenore Skenazy’s piece “Warning labels for hot dogs: Saving our children from a wurst-case scenario?” takes a satirical and humorous approach to the phenomenon of warning labels on commercial goods. The starting point for the text is the suggestion of the American Academy of Pediatrics that a “high risk” label be added to the packaging for hot dogs and other foods that can be hazardous for children as they may induce asphyxia. Skenazy takes a critical viewpoint of such warning labels, insofar as she suggests that the proliferation of such safety measures are symptomatic of a greater societal trend that borders on a certain hysteria in regards to normal aspects of living and life. Skenazy’s thesis is that “perfect safety is an impossible goal”, and by strictly regulating every mundane aspect of human life, what is occurring is actually a de-humanization of life. That is to say, such safety measures ultimately involve a sterilization of even the most common activities.

At the same time, this is not to suggest that the author is against such safety measures. They are certainly to a degree necessary, and she notes that safety labels have become ubiquitous. The author rather appeals to common sense – a trope all to common to such opinion pieces – to carefully delineate the limits of such safety measures. Skenazy’s main point is that such measures always have the danger of collapsing into a pure absurdity, as every aspect of human life, such as the mundane eating of a hot dog, can become potentially dangerous. Thus, this emphasis on regulation is also symptomatic of a certain pessimism prevalent in society, as the author notes: “We started to see everything as potentially unsafe, at least in a worst-case scenario.” This hyper-attentiveness to every detail and the pessimism that inevitably accompanies this hyper-attentiveness is almost pathological. Thus, Skenazy argues for a careful re-evaluation of what is truly potentially harmful and what is not. Skenazy essentially occupies the position that society must be responsible and maintain safety, yet simultaneously not turn this responsibility into a total hyperbole.

Skenazy certainly presents some compelling points. The over-regulation of society is equivalent to some type of neurosis, in which every event is perceived as potentially catastrophic. The identification of this problem in society and linking it to de-humanization is particularly potent, as life is precisely constituted by such mundane events and their potential dangers. Skenazy’s position against this hyperbolic societal response is an astute observation of the absurdities that a society that over-regulates itself inevitably generates. At the same time, Skenazy’s argumentative basis belies the seriousness of her argument. It is an approach that is informed by an appeal to  “common sense” approach and populism, suggesting that such over-regulation are merely the result of laws. She omits, for example, that such populism and common sense perspectives can be equally absurd. For example, Skenazy observes that companies began to place warning labels on all products in order to protect themselves from potential lawsuits. Such lawsuits, of course, are filed by the general populace. Therefore, the average proletariat is as guilty for the proliferation of such labels as any sector of industry. The normal accidents that constitute life are immediately blamed on the societal structure; at the same time this societal structure is used every time something goes wrong, for example, in the form of the aforementioned lawsuits.

Hence, Skenazy’s initial identification of the problem of over-regulation, while compelling, loses the sharpness of its analysis by relying on a common sense approach. What would make her arugment stronger is a more theoretical approach, rather than an appeal to populism and the lowest common denominator. As the cartoonist Scott Adams famously said, “You can never underestimate the stupidity of the general public.”

Time is precious

Time is precious

don’t waste it!

Get instant essay
writing help!
Get instant essay writing help!
Plagiarism-free guarantee

Plagiarism-free
guarantee

Privacy guarantee

Privacy
guarantee

Secure checkout

Secure
checkout

Money back guarantee

Money back
guarantee

Related Article Critique Samples & Examples

Virtual Reference Training: The Second Generation, Article Critique Example

In Virtual Reference Training: The Second Generation, author Lynn Westbrook seeks to expand the librarian’s understanding of the potentials and challenges within today’s increased familiarity [...]

Pages: 3

Words: 851

Article Critique

The Military and Pharmaceuticals: A Dangerous Mix, Article Critique Example

In his article, A Prescription for Tragedy, author Yochi J. Dreazen delves into the problem of soldier suicides that is plaguing America’s armed forces.  Dreazen [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 354

Article Critique

The Psychology of Prostitution, Article Critique Example

Prostitution is an age old profession, with descriptions of prostitutes occurring in ancient texts, such as the Bible. Researchers have long struggled with the question [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 374

Article Critique

English Program Evaluation in Saudi Context, Article Critique Example

The Relevance of Students Performance to Intensive  English Program Evaluation in Saudi Context. The review investigates the whole article on students’ performance towards an English [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 312

Article Critique

Early Advanced EFL Saudi Students, Article Critique Example

Content-Based Instruction and Corpus Lingusitics Curriculum for Early Advanced EFL Saudi Students. The review will examine the entire article on English as Foreign Language (EFL) [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 295

Article Critique

Education: Critique of Classroom-Based Scenarios, Article Critique Example

Scenario 1 Ms. Sara has a group of students who are off task regularly. She is not sure if they are off task for the [...]

Pages: 2

Words: 681

Article Critique

Virtual Reference Training: The Second Generation, Article Critique Example

In Virtual Reference Training: The Second Generation, author Lynn Westbrook seeks to expand the librarian’s understanding of the potentials and challenges within today’s increased familiarity [...]

Pages: 3

Words: 851

Article Critique

The Military and Pharmaceuticals: A Dangerous Mix, Article Critique Example

In his article, A Prescription for Tragedy, author Yochi J. Dreazen delves into the problem of soldier suicides that is plaguing America’s armed forces.  Dreazen [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 354

Article Critique

The Psychology of Prostitution, Article Critique Example

Prostitution is an age old profession, with descriptions of prostitutes occurring in ancient texts, such as the Bible. Researchers have long struggled with the question [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 374

Article Critique

English Program Evaluation in Saudi Context, Article Critique Example

The Relevance of Students Performance to Intensive  English Program Evaluation in Saudi Context. The review investigates the whole article on students’ performance towards an English [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 312

Article Critique

Early Advanced EFL Saudi Students, Article Critique Example

Content-Based Instruction and Corpus Lingusitics Curriculum for Early Advanced EFL Saudi Students. The review will examine the entire article on English as Foreign Language (EFL) [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 295

Article Critique

Education: Critique of Classroom-Based Scenarios, Article Critique Example

Scenario 1 Ms. Sara has a group of students who are off task regularly. She is not sure if they are off task for the [...]

Pages: 2

Words: 681

Article Critique

Get a Free E-Book ($50 in value)

Get a Free E-Book

How To Write The Best Essay Ever!

How To Write The Best Essay Ever!