Get a Free E-Book! ($50 Value)
HIRE A WRITER!
Paper Types
Disciplines
Get a Free E-Book! ($50 Value)

Student Interest in Education, Article Critique Example

Pages: 1

Words: 776

Article Critique

Abstract

Motivation is one of the most popular objects of education research. The degree to which students are motivated to learn largely predetermines their chances to achieve the desired learning outcomes. This paper is a review and critique of David H. Palmer’s article Student interest generated during an inquiry skills lesson. A brief summary of the article is provided. Hypotheses, methods, and results are discussed. Implications for education are provided.

Keywords: student, motivation, interest, learning, education, inquiry.

Student Interest in Education: Article Critique

How to motivate students to learn is an open question. David H. Palmer (2009) provides his view on the problem and explores student interest in and during an inquiry skills lesson. Palmer (2009) writes that “motivation can be defined as any process that initiates and maintains learning behavior” (p.147). Unfortunately, many science students have little or no motivation to learn (Palmer, 2009). Therefore, student motivation and ways to keep students motivated are the major challenges in science education (Palmer, 2009). This is why Palmer designs a study to assess the sources of situational interest during a science lesson (Palmer, 2009). Palmer (2009) concludes that, even when students lack inquiry skills, participation in inquiry-based science lesson tasks does increase student motivation to learn. The main sources of situational interest during a science class include learning and choice, physical activity, novelty, variety and surprise (Palmer, 2009). The researcher suggests that motivating science students to learn is not an unachievable task. Rather, these are education professionals and curriculum designers who should develop science curriculums, to foster social involvement, variety, and choice in the classroom.

The title of the article is equally interesting and confusing. On the one hand, education professionals need an in-depth understanding of the student motivation problem. On the other hand, the term “situational interest” is unclear. However, Palmer (2009) predicts thisconfusion and suggests that situational interest is entirely about short-term interest generated by various aspects of each particular situation. Thus, situational interest is always different, and researchers need to define what common aspects of the learning process can ensure high situational interest in all situations and settings.

Palmer’s (2009) study was designed to investigate situational interest and its main predictors during a science lesson. The author sought to answer two basic questions: (1) how much situational interest is there during a science lesson?; and (2) what are the main sources of situational interest? (Palmer, 2009) For the purpose of the study, Palmer (2009) focused on a hand-on inquiry skills lesson. The research sample included 224 grade nine students (Palmer, 2009). Five schools from one city in south-eastern Australia were invited to participate, with the same number of student volunteers taken from each school (Palmer, 2009). All schools were typical, with science lessons taught by specialist science teachers (Palmer, 2009). All students were divided into groups, each group carrying eight students who had to participate in a single 40-minute inquiry skills lesson (Palmer, 2009). All lessons were standardized around the four main components: Demonstration, Proposal, Experiment and Report (Palmer, 2009). Data were collected from students through a brief survey containing one single item (rating the lesson from very boring to very interesting) and group interviews at the end of each lesson (Palmer, 2009). The use of both qualitative and quantitative data had to ensure better validity of the study results.

The study indicated that students lacked skills to participate in inquiry-based lessons; nonetheless, inquiry-based approaches generated considerable situational interest among participants (Palmer, 2009). The main sources of situational interest for students were found to include learning, choice, physical activity, novelty, surprise, variety, and social involvement (Palmer, 2009). The most interesting was the link between situational interest and physical activity: Palmer (2009) suggests that physical activity is inseparable from variety, social involvement, autonomy, and concrete learning, all of which contribute to and stir situational interest in learning; yet, these assumptions require further empirical validation. Despite several limitations, the findings have far-reaching implications for education and learning. First, Palmer (2009) suggests that situational interest can provide a foundation for developing motivation models in learning. Situational interest is an extremely strong motivator of learning, and it has the potential to encourage low performing students to improve their learning achievements. Second, that novelty, choice, variety, and other factors generate student interest means that making students motivated is not an unachievable task. Unfortunately, it is not clear whether and how the findings of Palmer’s (2009) study can be generalized and applied in non-science disciplines. To a large extent, the discussed article is merely the first step to developing a single, salient model of student motivation across various disciplines.

References

Palmer, D.H. (2009). Student interest generated during an inquiry skills lesson. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 46(2), 147-165.

Time is precious

Time is precious

don’t waste it!

Get instant essay
writing help!
Get instant essay writing help!
Plagiarism-free guarantee

Plagiarism-free
guarantee

Privacy guarantee

Privacy
guarantee

Secure checkout

Secure
checkout

Money back guarantee

Money back
guarantee

Related Article Critique Samples & Examples

NYPD Shoots Man in Times Square, Article Critique Example

In the YouTube video, a man with dreadlocks, apparently high on some kind of drug, possibly methamphetamine, was shot by the New York Police after [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 297

Article Critique

Evaluating Research Problems, Article Critique Example

Chiloane (2010) presents a research problem dealing with South African business women after a time period of apartheid in which women could not hold property: [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 592

Article Critique

Masturbation as a Means of Achieving Sexual Health, Article Critique Example

Summary Statement This article by Dr. Eli Coleman, professor of Human Sexuality at the University of Minnesota Medical School, is divided into three main sections–1), [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 1163

Article Critique

Critical Behavior in Research, Article Critique Example

What ethical issue is at the heart of the article? Many scholars are concerned that guidelines on ethics need to be more assertive when dealing [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 844

Article Critique

The Impact of Culture on Childhood Development, Article Critique Example

The process of development in infancy, childhood and adolescence is inextricably intertwined with cultural factors. Development does not happen in a vacuum; while infants may [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 731

Article Critique

A Unified Theory of Development, Article Critique Example

Identify a major developmental model, discuss the model strengths and weaknesses. Identify your choice and reasons for your choice in the paper as well. A [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 646

Article Critique

NYPD Shoots Man in Times Square, Article Critique Example

In the YouTube video, a man with dreadlocks, apparently high on some kind of drug, possibly methamphetamine, was shot by the New York Police after [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 297

Article Critique

Evaluating Research Problems, Article Critique Example

Chiloane (2010) presents a research problem dealing with South African business women after a time period of apartheid in which women could not hold property: [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 592

Article Critique

Masturbation as a Means of Achieving Sexual Health, Article Critique Example

Summary Statement This article by Dr. Eli Coleman, professor of Human Sexuality at the University of Minnesota Medical School, is divided into three main sections–1), [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 1163

Article Critique

Critical Behavior in Research, Article Critique Example

What ethical issue is at the heart of the article? Many scholars are concerned that guidelines on ethics need to be more assertive when dealing [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 844

Article Critique

The Impact of Culture on Childhood Development, Article Critique Example

The process of development in infancy, childhood and adolescence is inextricably intertwined with cultural factors. Development does not happen in a vacuum; while infants may [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 731

Article Critique

A Unified Theory of Development, Article Critique Example

Identify a major developmental model, discuss the model strengths and weaknesses. Identify your choice and reasons for your choice in the paper as well. A [...]

Pages: 1

Words: 646

Article Critique

Get a Free E-Book ($50 in value)

Get a Free E-Book

How To Write The Best Essay Ever!

How To Write The Best Essay Ever!